1 Nephi 12-13: Catholicism

"Great & Abominable"

1 Nephi 12-13 is a kind of historical overview. It references the "Great and Abominable Church" without any other designation. 

However, in Protestantism and in Protestant America, the term was customarily attached to Catholicism. When I was growing up, there were still church members who linked the Catholic Church to the “Great and Abominable Church” (I grew up in upstate New York, so our congregation included ex-Catholics).

The link is far less palatable (and diplomatic) now, of course, and I got tired of it early on. Although some members liked to blame the Great Apostasy on the Council of Nicaea, it is obvious from reading the scriptures and history that (1) any apostasy within the early church occurred within that early church well before the end of the first century C.E. (See all of Paul's letters.)

(2) The Council of Nicaea actually preserved the most orthodox and non-crazy ideas of Christianity. That is, the Council preserved, as best as it was able, the concepts of an invested, non-abstract God and universal grace.

Yet, in truth, many nineteenth-century folks would have associated the “Great and Abominable Church” with Catholicism. Although the Reformation was nearly 300 years old at this point, it was still fresh in the American mind. Puritans left England due to persecution from the remnants of Catholicism, Anglicanism in the form of the Church of England. Europe was still a bastion, in the American Protestant mind, to Catholic influences. Truly radical Protestantism, went the thinking, couldn’t take root until the supposed stain of Catholicism was wiped away. This attitude lingered well into the twentieth century.

In fact, New Englanders got extremely nervous when Catholics, including the Catholic Irish, began to settle in Boston. Joseph Smith and his family left New England before the furor really ramped up but there is overlap. The Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk, a fictitious tale of scandal in a Catholic nunnery (rape, dead babies, secrets, catacombs) came out in 1836 (and was presented as non-fiction). 

The narrative of 1 Nephi 13 lends itself to an anti-Catholic interpretation but not entirely. After all, to many Protestants in the nineteenth century, Protestantism itself had faltered and gone down the wrong road--hence, the upsurge in Millennial sects. 

Joseph Smith, for instance, appears to have been entirely disinterested in going after Catholics specifically. It’s unlikely that he knew any anyway. Like Paul with The Law & paganism, Joseph Smith’s overall writing focuses on the analogy. Just as Paul continually used various analogies connected to legalism to go after the concept of propitiation (trying to win God or gods' favor), Joseph Smith used various analogies to attack the underlying causes of pride--such as fancy education and wealth and close-mindedness re: the Congregationalists that he grew up around--rather than a specific denomination.

Posts on Penance, Original Sin, and the Trinity to follow...